A female sports columnist in Chicago deals with the men in her life including her brother, her best friend and a sportswriter for a rival publication.
Cast:Jordana Spiro , Kyle Howard , Reid Scott , Michael Bunin , Jamie Kaler , Kellee Stewart , Jim Gaffigan , Mini Anden , Jay Tarses , Jeannie Gaffigan , Adrian Wenner , Billy Burke , Eddie McClintock , Lindsey Stoddart , Pat Finn , Michael Coleman , Zoe Perry , Rachael Harris
P.J. and the guys must replace Andy in their weekly poker game.
When P.J., Bobby, Stephanie and Kenny decide to have a couples-only dinner, Brendan and Mike answer back by going to a fancy bar together.
The gang goes on a pub crawl to celebrate Mike's birthday. Stephanie's book piques the interest of a film producer.
Brendan's new girlfriend is too much for him to handle. Bobby re-evaluates what it takes to be a man after meeting NASCAR driver Brian Vickers.
P.J. worries that the spark has gone out of her relationship with Bobby. Brendan makes a connection with Stephanie's sister. The bad economy hits Kenny's memorabilia shop.
Brendan announces he's moving out of P.J.'s apartment, Bobby looks for a new career, and Kenny tries to get into the business of organizing closets.
P.J. and Stephanie conduct a "dating intervention" on Mike and Brendan, respectively, to change their habits. Kenny and Bobby try working out to solidify their friendship.
Mike's relationship with Marcia continues to grow. A group of obnoxious college students ruins Crowley's for P.J. and the gang.
Brendan must make a decision that could affect everybody, Stephanie receives an offer to work in London, and P.J. can't help Mike plan a birthday party for Marcia.