When Marcy Bradford dies, she leaves her teenage daughter Nicole in the custody of two ex-boyfriends: straight-laced, formal Michael and wild artist Joey.
Cast:Paul Reiser , Greg Evigan , Staci Keanan , Florence Stanley , Giovanni Ribisi , Amy Hathaway , Dick Butkus , Chad Allen , Don Yesso , Dakin Matthews , Alitzah , Bradley Gregg , Jamie Rose , Richard Minchenberg , Davy Jones , Kellie Martin , Kim Johnston Ulrich , Max Perlich
Zach, a boy whom Nicole knew moves to New York and comes to see her. And Cory is not comfortable with her being with him.
When Nicole asks her more experienced girlfriend for kissing tips, Michael and Joey prepare for a fathers daughter talk by enrolling in a sexuality awareness seminar attended by a group of angry women over 30.
With Nicole away for the weekend, Michael and Joey resume a 15 year old bet that one of them can get their high school "no" queen of all time to say "yes" to a date.
Lifestyles and temperaments change dramatically in the Taylor/Harris household when Michael loses his job and Joey goes to work.
A visit from her rock and roll idol Malcolm O'Dell leaves Nicole star-struck until the musician loses his music making ability.
When 14 year old Nicole comes home with liquor on her breath, the Dads employ their own brand of shock therapy: a vivid and frightening demonstration of the dangers of alcohol abuse.
When a man whom the judge sent to prison sends her death threats, she's assigned someone to protect her--Bull Shannon from Night Court.
Nicole rebels when Joey ignores her objections to his dating a hot but condescending woman. Her revenge? She goes out with every fathers nightmare someone named Chopper.
When Nicole finds Joey in bed with a woman, her public bragging fuels Joey's already red hot reputation and gives Nicole, by association, a red hot reputation of her own.
Through a series of dreams, Nicole has a chance to see what life would have been like if her mother had married either Michael or Joey.
Michael is excited and Joey apprehensive as they begin their jobs together at a new financial magazine, but emotions mix when they meet their boss, Karen, an attractive and assertive woman.
In order to distract her over protective dads, Nicole introduces them to a beautiful new neighbor.
Shelby's crush on Michael wreaks havoc in her friendship with Nicole, then leads to heartbreak when Shelby mistakes a casual conversation for a romantic overture.
When Nicole fails to make the basketball team, Joey confronts her coach who turns out to be a very competitive woman both on and off the court.
Michael's uncle shows up and he's not exactly pleased to see him. It seems he has a habit of making promises that he doesn't keep. And he's making some to Nicole.
Nicole decides to drop out of an advanced English class - with best friend Shelby's encouragement, after overhearing Michael and Joey disdainfully discussing their "smart" boss, Karen.