Still A Mystery
Just because a case is closed doesn't mean the truth has been revealed. Suicide or murder? Runaway or kidnapping? Accidental or premeditated? Each episode of STILL A MYSTERY re-examines a single crime case where unanswered questions still remain. Through original interviews with law enforcement, family members and private investigators, news footage and social media, ... Read all
Genre: Crime
Cast:Benita Alexander-Noel , Andrew McPherson , Larry Mihlon , Stacy Bridavsky , April Moore , Ray Moore , Heidi Hemmat , Cassie Fambro , Tim Ratcliff , Selma Eikelenboom , Etienne Maurice , Doug McHenry , Briana Whitney , Kelly Osborn , Sierra Harrop , Michael Mooney , Jessica Oh , Sherry Ballard
S1.E1 ∙ The dangerous houses
18-year-old Brookelyn Farthing disappears in 2013 after attending a party in the small town of Berea, Kentucky. And then, 24-year-old Lindsay Buziak, a young beautiful realtor, is found brutally killed after showing some new clients a million-dollar home.
S1.E2 ∙ Down the hill
13-year-old Abby Williams and 14-year-old Libby German go for a short walk on a popular hiking trail and then disappear. And then 13-year-old Dylan Redwine vanishes on Thanksgiving break, 2012, while visiting his dad in Vallecito, Colorado.
S1.E3 ∙ The midnight murders
Carla Stefaniak, a spirited Florida insurance agent with a passion for travel, heads to Costa Rica. But on the day she's supposed to return, she vanishes. And in 2014, 19-year-old college student Pravin Varughese disappears after a party.
S1.E4 ∙ Secrets in the cars
After a night out with friends, 20-year-old Jaleayah Davis is found dead in the midst of a horrifying scene. And 21-year-old Kelsie Schelling, drives two hours to show her boyfriend a sonogram of the baby, but never makes it home.
S1.E5 ∙ The gone girls
In July, 2018, 25-year-old Danniella Vian, a young mother from Mobile, Alabama, disappears into thin air. And then 19-year-old Holly Moore's suspicious death still raises questions four years after her body is found hanging from her closet.
S2.E1 ∙ The Party Murders
From the Investigation Discovery website: Their evenings begin as fun celebrations with friends but they end in murder. With disturbing evidence, terrifying theories, and demands for justice, can the mystery of how two young party-goers are murdered be solved?
S2.E2 ∙ Terror After Midnight
A young Hollywood celebrity is out celebrating her birthday, and another young woman enjoys a late drink with friends. Just a few hours later, they both end up dead.
S2.E3 ∙ Brides and Murder
The dreams of two young brides-to-be are tragically cut short. Desperate calls made to 911 could reveal the truth about their shocking deaths.
S2.E4 ∙ She Gave No Warning
They are head over heels in love with their whole lives ahead still ahead of them, but then they die suddenly under suspicious circumstances. Could the strange text messages that come from their own phones hold the clues that investigators need?
S2.E5 ∙ Young Love Gone Wrong
They are head over heels in love with their whole lives ahead still ahead of them, but then they die suddenly under suspicious circumstances. Could the strange text messages that come from their own phones hold the clues that investigators need?
S2.E6 ∙ TV Dreams Cut Short
Two young women's dream of big success as television anchors come to a violent end. They are murdered in their own apartments and there are no signs of forced entry.
S2.E7 ∙ Killers Among Us
A respected police officer heads home after a late shift, and a young man who has just moved into his own place relaxes after watching football.
S2.E8 ∙ Innocence Interrupted
The murders of a teenage boy and a teenage girl devastate their communities.
S2.E9 ∙ Her Last Night Out
They head out into the night, full of youthful life and promise, but they never come back. Clues that come from behind bars could help solve the mysteries that surround the disturbing disappearances of these two women.
S2.E10 ∙ Who Pulled the Trigger?
A look at the case of victims of shootings that seem senseless.
S2.E11 ∙ The Hidden Bodies
They planned to change their course after struggling during their early years but ended up dead in such a brutal way.
S2.E12 ∙ Why Did She Leave?
She is an innocent bride-to-be; he's a six-year-old schoolboy. Both are on the road, away from home, when they disappear. When her car and body are found, will the clues lead to her murderer? And will his family ever solve the mystery of his vanishing?
S2.E13 ∙ The Hidden Clues
Two 20-year-olds suffer personal tragedies then have their own lives abruptly snuffed out. He's shot while hanging out with friends; she disappears, only to turn up dead in a staged suicide. Will their families be able to prove what really happened?
S2.E14 ∙ Eyes on Her
Two young women are savagely murdered. One has gone fishing only to turn up beaten and drowned, and the other is a pregnant mother attacked while on the job delivering newspapers.
S2.E15 ∙ Guns and Secrets
One young woman is found with a shotgun wound to her head shortly after moving in with her new boyfriend. Then, a couple planning their wedding are gunned down in their own backyard.
S2.E16 ∙ Death and Silence
The body of a young musician turns up in an alley. Police learn she's been spending time with an older man. And when a construction worker disappears on the job, his coworkers' accounts don't add up.
S2.E17 ∙ Clues Caught on Camera
A mother of three is gunned down in a church basement where she's set to teach a fitness class. Police find surveillance video showing a figure in full police body armor stalking the floor in the lead-up to the slaughter.
S3.E0 ∙ Shelbey Thornburgh
This segment details the homicide of Shelbey Thornburgh, age 20, Houston, Texas, November 4, 2015: Beautiful Shelbey Thornburgh moved to Houston, Texas, to pursue her dreams of becoming a model. One night she was found murdered in her apartment, unclothed, with a horrific slash across her neck. Investigators are left wondering what happened to her.
S3.E1 ∙ My Brother's Keeper
When LeRyan Nicohson's sisters investigate his disappearance, they uncover a series of secrets that lead to the heartbreaking truth; Parris Hopson's disappearance may be connected to LeRyan's violent death years earlier.
S3.E2 ∙ In Her Own Home
A beautiful college student is found stabbed to death in her bed. Police immediately find the murder weapon and an eyewitness, but the case stalls. And, another beloved young woman is bludgeoned to death in her home.
S3.E3 ∙ Targeted in the Night
Two unsolved murders are investigated: 1. On June 26, 2009, a 10-year-old girl, Lindsay Baum of McCleary, Washington, was walking home from her friend's house at dusk and then mysteriously vanished within a few blocks. Her remains were found in Eastern Washington eight years later. Detectives are still working the unsolved case. 2. During the early hours of September 13, 2015, in Stockton, California, Timothy "Tim" Egkan was discovered dead, lying face-down on the sidewalk with some bruising on his body. He had been walking to his home. He died of a stab wound to his torso that severed his aorta. A botched robbery was ruled out by investigators, because his belongings were confirmed to still be with him. Detectives are still working the unsolved case.
S3.E4 ∙ Murdered in Broad Daylight
When Aliza Sherman is stabbed to death, police are convinced the attack was premeditated, and Aliza may have known her killer. Then, the fire that kills Sheila Deviney is ruled an accident, until new evidence points to arson and murder.
S3.E5 ∙ Depths of Depravity
The body of a 20-year-old woman turns up in the most gruesome way imaginable severed and stuffed into trash bags. One detective's frustrated pursuit of the prime suspect prompts a horrifying question: Could this man be a serial killer?
S3.E6 ∙ Who Wanted Him Dead?
A US soldier who's been to war in two foreign lands meets harm in Upstate New York and his killers may have been his fellow GIs. Then, a young father and aspiring politician disappears, with the main clue his last, haunting voicemail.
S3.E7 ∙ Best Lives Cut Short
When entrepreneur Ash Rowell's good life is cut short after he's gunned down, police suspect a hit. Suspicion falls on his own family members. Then, after a long night of partying, two friends' overdoses may turn out to be something more sinister.
S3.E8 ∙ New Beginnings Violent Endings
Dorian Bluford moves to a new city to be closer to a friend. His family doesn't know he's murdered, stabbed 37 times in the chest. Police rule out the new friend, but who could have committed what seems like a crime of passion.
S3.E9 ∙ He Didn't Have to Die
Eric Cates is discovered dead in his pickup truck. Cops suggest suicide, but his mother is convinced of foul play.
S3.E10 ∙ Somebody Knows Something
Families of a college student and a mother of five are left stunned as their loved ones disappear and complicated conspiracies arise.
S3.E11 ∙ Small Town Secrets
After he graduates second in his high school class and excels in college, Cole decides to take time off to work in Minnesota, far from his Florida home. When he vanishes, his parents are bewildered to learn he was last seen in Benson, North Carolina, on a mysterious trip with a pair of co-workers. His colleagues' stories keep changing, but it becomes clear that they were embarked on a very dangerous mission. Find Cole Thomas #JusticeForCole Then, in Jamestown, New York, Yolanda, a young mother of four disappears, her car the only trace left behind. When a massive search is undertaken, secrets rise to the surface, and the town discovers a clandestine tryst with one of the officers searching for Yolanda. @Justice for Yolanda Bindics.
S3.E12 ∙ Charmed by a Killer
One mom is missing, and another spurs a manhunt for her daughter's killer.
S3.E13 ∙ Suspects at Large
In an ironic twist, a woman vanishes while looking for her missing friend.
S4.E1 ∙ Southern Secrets
When two women die suddenly under mysterious circumstances, authorities initially suspect suicide. But both of their families believe it was murder, and are trying to figure out who is responsible.
S4.E2 ∙ She Turns Up Dead
A mother of two and a young woman planning a career in science both die under mysterious circumstances, and two families embark on quests for justice.
S4.E3 ∙ More Than Meets the Eye
What seems like a murder-suicide of a mom and her young son may be something else entirely. Next, when three young health care workers are murdered in succession, police fear the same killer could be responsible.
S4.E4 ∙ The Death of Innocence
Two Stories: 1. A 22-year-old National Guard officer with a bright future in law enforcement drowns in water only a few inches deep. 2. A 13-year-old cheerleader disappears, and authorities turn up evidence that may point to a gruesome murder.
S4.E5 ∙ North Carolina Unsolved
A rookie police officer is heard confronting someone with a gun and is shot in the back of the head, but the D.A. believes it's suicide.
S4.E6 ∙ Where The Clues Lead
Two Stories: 1. He seems like a great partner. But when Susan Osborne and her 14-year-old son Evan disappear, it turns out Mr. Right has a secret. 2. When a young man is shot in a street confrontation, all clues point to one man. Could this case be that simple?
S4.E7 ∙ Far from Home
Two Stories: 1. A young woman's body is found 200 miles from home, and a retired police detective uses his podcast to crowd-source the search for her killer. 2. When a young mother disappears, an old answering machine message could hold the key to finding her murderer.
S4.E8 ∙ Missing Blue Eyes
Two Stories: 1. A seven-month-old baby vanishes from his crib, and a family descends into an unimaginable nightmare. 2. When a young mom disappears, there's no shortage of men in town for police to question.
S4.E9 ∙ A Community Betrayal
Two Stories: 1. When a 14-year-old boy goes missing, people in the neighborhood seem to know what happened, but no one calls the police. 2. When authorities find a woman's dead, naked body, investigators hope DNA evidence will help find those responsible.
S4.E10 ∙ The Silent Witnesses
Two Stories: 1. A young woman embarks on a trip to her father's homeland and is brutally murdered, and a young mother and her baby are shot as they are driving. 2. Now the search is on to bring the killers to justice.
S5.E1 ∙ Taken Before Graduation
Secrets and coverups thwart police trying to solve two student murders: 1. Weeks before graduation, officers find the body of a Georgia high school senior, Rhonda Sue Coleman, who had been completely burned, sparking a decades-long quest for justice. 2. In South Carolina, a promising college student, Shelton J. Sanders, disappears after scouting bachelor party locations with a friend.
S5.E2 ∙ Danger at Close Range
Two stories are outlined. 1. A bride-to-be vanishes weeks before her wedding. Suspicion swirls around her fiancé and ex-boyfriend, before a shocking revelation about a coworker makes him the main person of interest. 2. A mysterious death of a young trans woman is discussed.
S5.E3 ∙ Indiana Unsolved
Two stories are outlined. 1. On September 28, 2015, 20-year-old Joseph W. Smedley II, a student at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana, sends his sister Vivianne Bernas a cryptic message about leaving town to move overseas. Three days later on October 2, 2015, his body is found in Griffy Lake, weighted down by a backpack filled with 66 pounds of rocks. The authorities declare the case to be a suicide, but the family disagrees. The family has not had adequate access to the police files and are still looking for answers. 2. On July 6, 2004, 22-year-old Molly Laura Dattilo of Indianapolis, Indiana disappeared. She was last seen with John Shelton, a violent man with a prison record who is a person of interest, along with John's father, Edward Shelton. In October 2008, a caller to a tip line shared information that John Shelton told his father Edward Shelton that he had "accidentally" killed a girl. The family members sued John Shelton in civil court and won their case. However, they still do not have answers about what happened and the police do not have enough evidence to further the case. Molly Dattilo was legally declared dead, but the family still wants answers.
S5.E4 ∙ The Party's Over
Two stories are outlined. 1. Mitrice Richardson, age 24, went missing on September 17, 2009 after police released her from a jail in Calabasas, California, where she had been taken after behaving erratically at a restaurant. She was missing for 11 months before being found deceased in August 2010 by park rangers. Her parents have not gotten straight answers from the authorities as to why they let her walk off alone into the dark night with no cell phone, purse or money. Those items were in her car, which the police had put in an impound lot. 2. Ft. Hood, Killeen, Texas soldier Christopher Ferguson, age 21, either fell, or was pushed, from a 3rd story apartment balcony on March 18, 2007. He died at the hospital. He was attending a party with several of his friends. Christopher's sister, Christina McDonald, has been unable to get a clear explanation from the authorities about the actual circumstances of his death. The Army ruled his death a suicide.
S5.E5 ∙ Suspicious Circumstances
Two stories are outlined, and the families of these two young mothers who die in suspicious circumstances are searching for answers. 1. November 2001. Racheyl Smith Brinson was having problems in her marriage and had told others that she was thinking about asking for a divorce. Racheyl's husband Steve Brinson was allegedly an abusive partner. He claims that his wife fell to her death while hunting at the Mumford Island Hunting Club in Woodbine, Georgia. 2. April 2019. Bayview Neighborhood in San Francisco, California: The boyfriend of Jessica Nicole Alva, Clayton Rhoades, was released from prison in January 2019 and moved in with Jessica. He claims that she hanged herself. Jessica's family suspects foul play in death of woman investigated by police as a suspected suicide.
S5.E6 ∙ What the Trees Know
STORY 1. Wilkes County, Georgia, September 23, 2012: A Georgia man, 35-year-old Jeffrey Gebhardt, suffers 17 stab wounds while on a deer hunting trip with his friend David Smith, and authorities rule his death a suicide, shocking his family. STORY 2. Pemberton, British Columbia, Canada: 26-year-old Marshal Iwaasa disappears on November 17, 2019 without warning. Six days later, his burned-out vehicle is found by hikers on November 23, 2019, 700 miles and 14 hours away from where anyone saw him last in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada. Local law enforcement has closed the case and Marshal's family is desperate for answers.
S5.E7 ∙ Suffer the Children
STORY 1. Oakley Carlson, age 4, disappeared from Grays Harbor, Washington in February 2021. No one can find her, including her foster parents and her biological parents, Andrew Carlson and Jordan Bowers, who are currently under investigation for having told falsehoods to law enforcement that were debunked. Oakley had spent about three years with a foster family, Erik and Jamie Jo Hiles, before she was legally returned to her parents, Carlson and Bowers. STORY 2. March 31, 2018, Wheat Ridge, Colorado: A young mother, Jennifer Myers, born December 17, 1986 and now age 31, leaves a bar with a much older man, age 65, that she doesn't know and ends up dead in his house from a shotgun wound to her head. The main suspect, Randy Allen William, born on August 9, 1953, is the only suspect. There are many inconsistencies in this suspected murder case, but the Wheat Ridge Police Department rules this case a suicide. Jennifer's family is baffled and wants answers to their questions, such as: If the death was truly a suicide, why was the shotgun that killed her found outside by a fence on Randy William's property? Why was Randy William shown on a surveillance camera carrying two rifle cases out of his house before he called 911? Since Randy William was a former paramedic, why did he offer Jennifer no help? The family has many more questions they would like answered.
S5.E8 ∙ Secrets in the DNA
STORY 1. A truck driver finds an unconscious woman on a Missouri highway, and police determine the suspect attacked her elsewhere and placed her on the road. STORY 2. An unknown killer bludgeons a mother and her daughters at their home while her son and nephew cling to life.
S5.E9 ∙ Unseen Enemies
STORY 1. The murder of billionaire couple Barry and Honey Sherman in their mansion stuns Toronto, Ontario, Canada since Barry is a pharmaceutical mogul with many enemies, but it is unclear who would kill his wife. STORY 2. A New York teenager disappears after a mysterious road trip.
S5.E10 ∙ The Stuff of Nightmares
STORY 1. 14-year-old Max DeVries from Brighton, Michigan disappears in May 2004 under suspicious circumstances while on vacation with his mother, sister and Aunt in Aruba. Max was last seen in the ocean riding jet skis with an older man. His disappearance happened a year before the disappearance of Natalee Holloway in 2005, but did not get as much press coverage. The investigation into his unusual disappearance remains active. STORY 2. August 19, 1992: A man kidnaps Laurie J. Depies, age 20 at the time, from the parking lot of her boyfriend's apartment complex in the former town of Menasha, Wisconsin, which is now known as Fox Crossing. Laurie's family is extremely frustrated that Laurie's case is still unsolved, but there is very limited physical evidence in this heartrending case.
